Which is Better, Farmer’s Dog or Ollie in America?

Both Farmer’s Dog and Ollie are top choices for fresh dog food in America. However, Farmer’s Dog is slightly better if you want meals that are 100% personalized, made with human-grade ingredients, and recommended by vets. But if you’re looking for more recipe variety and a slightly lower price, Ollie is also a great option.

Let’s take a close look at what makes each brand special and help you decide what’s best for your dog.

What Are Farmer’s Dog and Ollie?

Farmer’s Dog and Ollie are popular fresh dog food delivery companies in the U.S. They deliver pre-made meals that are healthier than traditional kibble.

Why Are People Switching to Fresh Dog Food?

• More natural and healthy
  Fresh food is made with real meat and vegetables. It doesn’t have chemicals or fake stuff like many store-bought dog foods.
• Helps with digestion and allergies
  Many dogs have stomach or skin issues from dry food. Fresh food is easier to digest and often helps with itching or upset tummies.
• Tastier for dogs
  Dogs love the smell and taste of real food. Mealtime becomes exciting!

Ingredients: Which Brand Has Better Quality?

Farmer’s Dog Ingredients

• Made with human-grade meats and veggies
  Farmer’s Dog uses the same kind of ingredients that humans eat. They include beef, turkey, pork, and chicken, along with veggies like sweet potatoes, carrots, and lentils.
• No fillers, no preservatives
  There are no harmful chemicals, by-products, or corn. Everything is clean, fresh, and simple — perfect for dogs with allergies or sensitive stomachs.
• Vet-approved recipes
  All meals are designed with vets to make sure dogs get the right balance of protein, fat, vitamins, and minerals.

Ollie Ingredients

• Fresh food with added superfoods
  Ollie Dog Food also uses real meats and veggies. It includes healthy extras like chia seeds, cod liver oil, and blueberries to support brain and heart health.
• More recipe choices
  Ollie offers four protein options: beef, chicken, turkey, and lamb. That gives your dog more variety and helps if they are picky eaters.
• No artificial flavors or fillers
  Just like Farmer’s Dog, Ollie stays away from soy, corn, or wheat, and keeps its recipes simple and clean.

Price Comparison: Which One Costs Less?

Farmer’s Dog Cost

• More expensive, more personalized
  Farmer’s Dog is fully customized for each dog, so it’s a bit more costly. Plans start at about $2/day for small dogs and can go up to $10/day for large dogs.
• Long-term health benefits
  Many dog owners say they save on vet bills because their dogs stay healthier on Farmer’s Dog food.

Ollie Cost

• More affordable
  Ollie starts at about $1.50/day for small dogs, making it easier on your wallet while still giving high-quality meals.
• Topper plan available
  You can also choose a topper plan, which lets you mix Ollie with dry food to save money and still get fresh benefits.

Health and Nutrition: Which Brand is Better for Dogs?

Farmer’s Dog Nutrition

• Ideal for dogs with health issues
  If your dog has allergies, joint pain, or stomach problems, Farmer’s Dog gives you highly customized meals that can help.
• Built by real veterinarians
  Their team of experts makes sure every meal supports your dog’s age, weight, and health conditions.
• All-natural nutrition
  No grains, no junk, just balanced proteins, carbs, and fats to keep your dog active and happy.

Ollie Nutrition

• Great for general health
  Ollie’s meals help dogs maintain a healthy weight, stronger muscles, and better digestion. It’s a smart upgrade from kibble.
• Superfoods add extra value
  Ingredients like fish oil and spinach help with brain function, coat shine, and overall immunity.
• Less customization than Farmer’s Dog
  Ollie offers great food, but it’s not as deeply personalized for dogs with special health needs.

Delivery & Packaging: What’s Easier?

Farmer’s Dog Delivery

• Frozen delivery with dry ice
  Your meals come frozen and packed in dry ice, so they stay cold until you’re ready to use them. Each pack includes clear feeding instructions.
• Portioned by the meal
  No need to guess! Meals are pre-measured for your dog, so you just open, pour, and serve.
• Recyclable packaging
  The boxes and insulation are eco-friendly and easy to recycle.

Ollie Delivery

• Fresh delivery on your schedule
  Ollie gives you more control over when your food arrives. You can pause, skip, or change delivery dates anytime.
• Comes with scoop and storage container
  Ollie includes a food scoop and a handy container in your first box to make storage easy and mess-free.
• Also eco-friendly
  Ollie uses recyclable trays and insulation that keep your dog’s food safe and the planet cleaner.

Taste and Dog Happiness: What Do Dogs Like More?

Farmer’s Dog Taste

• Smells like real food
  Dogs often love Farmer’s Dog meals because they smell like home-cooked dinner — fresh and meaty.
• Good for picky eaters
  If your dog doesn’t usually like food, Farmer’s Dog might change that. Many owners say their dogs started eating better right away.
• Goes down easily
  The soft texture and warm smell make it perfect for older dogs or dogs with teeth issues.

Ollie Taste

• Fun recipe choices
  Ollie’s four flavors give dogs a variety. This keeps mealtime exciting and helps if your dog likes to try new things.
• Great smell and texture
  The meals are soft, easy to chew, and smell good — even to humans! Dogs usually finish their bowls fast.
• Perfect for mixing
  If you want to use Ollie as a topper with kibble, it mixes well and still tastes great.

How Long Can Ollie and Farmer’s Dog Food Stay Fresh in the Fridge?

Ollie dog food can stay fresh in the fridge for up to 4 days after opening, while Farmer’s Dog food lasts about 4 to 5 days once thawed. To keep the food safe, always store it in its original packaging or an airtight container. Fresh dog food should never be left out at room temperature for more than 2 hours. Before feeding, check for any bad smell, color change, or unusual texture. If the food looks or smells off, it’s best to throw it away.

Real Customer Reviews: What Are People Saying?

Farmer’s Dog Reviews

• 5-star reviews from pet parents
  Owners say their dogs are more energetic, have better poop, and fewer health problems after switching.
• Vets recommend it
  Many customers say their vet suggested trying Farmer’s Dog, and they were glad they did.
• Great for sensitive dogs
  If your dog has food allergies or stomach problems, Farmer’s Dog often brings real improvement.

Ollie Reviews

• Loved for simplicity and results
  People like how easy it is to manage Ollie deliveries and say their dogs seem happier and more playful.
• Works well with mixed diets
  Some owners use Ollie with dry food and still see big benefits, like shinier coats and better digestion.
• Customer service is helpful
  Ollie’s support team is easy to reach and quickly solves any issues with delivery or orders.

Quick Comparison Table

Final Verdict: Which Is Better?

Choose Farmer’s Dog if:

• Your dog has allergies, sensitive digestion, or health issues.
• You want the best personalization and top-level ingredients.
• You don’t mind paying a little more for top quality.

Choose Ollie if:

• You want high-quality fresh food at a lower price.
• You like more recipe options for your dog.
• You want to mix fresh food with kibble or switch slowly.

Both are excellent. Farmer’s Dog wins for premium health and vet-level care, while Ollie is a budget-friendly option with great results.